Thursday, December 24, 2015

Jonah Goldberg: The War on Christmas (excerpts)

[L]et me just say that I love Christmastime and I take no offense whatsoever when someone says to me, “Merry Christmas.” Indeed, I think it is written somewhere in the Talmud that if you make someone feel bad for sincerely wishing you a “Merry Christmas!” it means you’re a miserable, joyless ass (it sounds more high-minded in the original Hebrew). Of course, there’s a flip side to that. If you know someone is not Christian or hates Christmas for some reason, and you say “Merry Christmas” out of spite or vindictiveness, rather than with joy and good cheer, then you are the one putting the “ass” in Christmass. And that is part of the genius of the Left’s passive-aggressive war on Christmas. By forcing Christmas-lovers — Christian and non-Christian alike — to take time out of their day to marshal a metaphorically martial defense of Christmas, they further undermine the whole point of the holiday, and the Holy Day. Turning Christmas into a battleground in the culture war compounds the damage they’re already doing.

The war on Christmas can best be understood as the point at which several tectonic plates of the culture grind together. When they grind together really hard, we get earthquakes. The plates have been grinding together for generations, and they go by many names: secular humanism, nihilism, relativism, progressivism, Cthulhu, and others. The opposing forces have a lot of monikers as well: traditionalism, Christianity, conservatism, and, my favorite, the Good Guys. Christmas just happens to be one of the places where the Good Guys and Cthulhu fight on ground really favorable to the Good Guys. That’s because, properly speaking, Christmas should be about as controversial as puppies, kittens, motherhood, and Scotch: Just one of those things everyone agrees is a good thing. Indeed, that’s the underlying assumption among Christmas’s cable-show champions: Christmas used to be something that united us — but not anymore, thanks to the secular humanists, multiculturalists, and other killjoys. And that’s absolutely true. Christmas was uncontroversial for a while. Then it was controversial. Then it was uncontroversial. And so on. That’s because Christmas is in fact older than cable TV.

Thanks to Charles Dickens, Christmas became a time when parents thought about the Christmas they wished they had had when they were kids. And so they set out to deliver it to their own children. That’s one of the keys to Christmas’s enduring popularity. As Bill Murray says in Scrooged (you knew I’d come back to that), at Christmastime, however briefly, “We are the people we always hoped we would be.”

....take comfort in the knowledge that the Christmas haters are not merely losers, they are losing. Most Americans — who spend almost a trillion dollars a year at Christmastime by the way — understand those people are idiots. If anything, Christmas keeps winning in the war on Christmas because Christmas is so much Odin-damn fun! So enjoy the holiday on Dickensian grounds — faith, family, fun all mixed into one. Say “Merry Christmas” with joy in your heart and have a good time — if for no other reason than the fact that nothing pisses off the people who hate Christmas more than people actually enjoying Christmas. And by all means, let us redouble our efforts in our defensive war against relativism or the relentless erosion of our culture by political correctness. But there are other days of the year to have those arguments. The whole point of Christmas is not to have arguments. That’s what Thanksgiving dinner is for.

9 comments:

Meade said...

Merry Christmas to you and all your Lemmings, Lem. And may you find much levity now and in the new year.

Meade said...

also... Happy Holidays.

AllenS said...

Went to the grocery store in New Richmond this morning. Everyone had on a Santa Clause hat except for the one black woman, who was wearing a dark maroon do-rag.

ricpic said...

Merry Christmas to All.

And much thanks for this site.

One of the most fascinating things to me about Christmas is that I see people in the local supermarket who I never see the rest of the year. You get to know the regulars, both those you say hello to and those you know be repeated sightings but there's a whole crew that pack the market the week before Christmas Day who I guess are holed up the rest of the year. Tis a puzzlement.

Lem the artificially intelligent said...

You are welcome ricpic.

edutcher said...

Merry Christmas to all the Lemmings.

BTW, if you want to know how lousy it is to be a Lefty, check out this little ode to Christmas joy from the Lefties at the Guardian.

Now you know why Ritmo's the way he is.

ampersand said...

Merry Christmas everyone. Hope you've been good or you'll end up here

Leland said...

Merry Christmas Lem and to your fellow cobloggers and those of your commenters who believe.

Methadras said...

I tell people Merry Christmas regardless of who they are. If they don't like it, it's not my problem. My country, my national holiday. Deal.