Tuesday, August 6, 2013

The big easychair


Here is a set of quotes I found at Kevin Kelly’s Technium blog. Kelly was the first to use the word technium to describe the inseparability of man from technology. That is, being technological is what makes us human. He believes that as time goes on we will become more and more entwined with our technology because technology is an extension of us. Kelly is quoting from Douglas Coupland’s, Marshall McLuhan: You Know Nothing of My Work. McLuhan is most famous for having said, “the medium is the message.”  If you have ever given up television for a couple months, and upon watching again for the first time felt your muscles and mind relax, this is what McLuhan meant. It is not what you watch, but that you watch.

In 1962 McLuhan wrote, "Instead of tending towards a vast Alexandrian library the world has become a computer, an electronic brain, exactly as an infantile piece of science fiction. And as our senses have gone outside us, Big Brother goes inside. So, unless aware of this dynamic, we shall at once move into a phase of panic terrors, exactly befitting a small world of tribal drums, total interdependence, and superimposed co-existence."
“The medium is the message” means that the ostensible content of all electronic media is insignificant; it is the medium itself that has the greater impact on the environment, a fact bolstered by the now medically undeniable fact that the technologies we use every day begin, after a while, to alter the way our brains work, and hence the way we experience our world. Forget the ostensible content, say, of a television program. All that matters is that you’re watching the TV itself.
Marshall’s other cliché, “the global village,” is a way of paraphrasing the fact that electronic technologies are an extension of the human central nervous system, and that our planet’s collective neural wiring would create a single 24-7 blobby, fuzzy, quasi-sentient metacommunity. And one must remember that Marshall arrived at these conclusions not by hanging around, say, NASA or IBM, but rather by studying arcane sixteenth-century Reformation pamphleteers, the writings of James Joyce, and Renaissance perspective drawings. He was a master of pattern recognition, the man who bangs a drum so large that it’s only beaten once every hundred years.
And here we are, 50 years later living out his prediction. How worried should we be? Should an alarm be sounded, or shall we go gently into this brave new world?


55 comments:

Trooper York said...

Nothing is worse than listening to some pointed headed intellectual tell you "I don't watch TV." Like it was beneath him and he spends all his time reading boring Russian Novels and composing sonnets to his freaking cat.

Everybody watches TV. Lot's of TV. They are aware of what is on TV and what is the latest thing. You can't avoid it.

Stop with the pretentions you annoying twits!

Trooper York said...

God bless Honey Boo Boo, Theresa Giudice and those Duck guys.

They are what separates us from the terrorists.

deborah said...

Open your eyes, Trooper, the reality TV craze is the beginning of the middle of the end. It's terrifying.

WWIII Joe Biden, Husk-Puppet + America's Putin said...

I hardly watch any TV. I hate it.
I'm not bragging. I'd like to watch it, since I pay a bloody lot for it.
I just hate it. I see liberal bias everywhere. If it's not liberal bias, it's mindless shallow youth vanity. I don't even watch BBT anymore. I have all the DVDs.
I like PBS. Just like some dang liberal-- I like the PBS Create channel so much, when I do turn on the TV (as a sleep aid) that's what I watch.
Rick Steves, Joseph Rosendo, Rudy Maxa, Jacques Pepin - then zzzzzz.
I refuse to watch AM tv. I hate the morning show blow-hards. All of them. Just the sound of Matt Lauers voice send me into a homicidal rage.

I don't get fox news so I miss out on red eye. I cannot stand the leftwing bias of comedy central or that blowhard Nazi Conan O'Brien who only mocks republicans and thinks no one will notice.
TV - blek.

And the mainstream tv shows - all those stupid violent crime shows that litter prime-time. If I had children, I throw the tv out the window.
My kids would hate me because they would not be allowed to watch that garbage.

edutcher said...

TV stopped being good when the left black&white behind.

Trooper York said...

Nothing is worse than listening to some pointed headed intellectual tell you "I don't watch TV." Like it was beneath him and he spends all his time reading boring Russian Novels and composing sonnets to his freaking cat.

Not unlike the guy who "read Playboy for the articles".

edutcher said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Sydney said...

medically undeniable fact that the technologies we use every day begin, after a while, to alter the way our brains work...

Is this really undeniably true? I am skeptical.

ndspinelli said...

Trooper is a reality tv junkie. He needs a good 12 step program.

deborah said...

Except for Project Runway :)

deborah said...

I don't know, Sydney. Would you feel any physical or mental symptoms if you walked away from the computer for a week? (Not including your direct work.)

Eric the Fruit Bat said...

I blame Gutenberg.

Icepick said...

They are what separates us from the terrorists.

If Honey Boo Boo is cancelled the terrorists have won?

Trooper York said...

Reality TV is just TV returning to it's roots. Game shows and documentaries and quiz shows with real people is where TV started. With the occasional drama from a live play that was televised.

There is a lot of crap on TV. But some stuff that is better than anything in the movies. It is not all great. But it is not all crap either.

Trooper York said...

That's right Icepick.

If the cancel the show featuring toothless illiterate goobers than how will anyone know what it is like to live in Florida? Just sayn'

Icepick said...

If the cancel the show featuring toothless illiterate goobers than how will anyone know what it is like to live in Florida? Just sayn'

This is true. All the Yankees and Cubans that have moved here do seem to need a lot of dental work.

Trooper York said...

That's right.

That Steve Guttenberg started the downward spiral with his stupid "Police Academy" movies.

Next thing you know every other show is a police comedy. Crapola.

Trooper York said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
deborah said...

No it's not all crap. There's so much good stuff that I could easily watch it all my waking hours. I'm having a problem disconnecting these days.

Trooper York said...

Just watch the View for a few minutes.

You can click off and stay away from the TV for a couple days after watching that crap.

WWIII Joe Biden, Husk-Puppet + America's Putin said...

The View- that's all I'm saying. 10 seconds of The View is enough to send any rational person to the loony bin.

Trooper York said...

Best part of your post....Mom taking a drag on her cigarette while she is watching TV.

I miss the 1950's.

Sydney said...

Would you feel any physical or mental symptoms if you walked away from the computer for a week?

No, I wouldn't. Would any of you?

Unknown said...

Would you feel any physical or mental symptoms if you walked away from the computer for a week?

No, I wouldn't. Would any of you?


Internet, yes. TV, not at all. I find that even when I want to watch TV I usually can't find anything that I want to watch.

Trooper York said...

Well if we walked away from the computer we would have to put on pants.

And who wants that?

Icepick said...

Well if we walked away from the computer we would have to put on pants.

And who wants that?


You go commando on the intertubez? Not me. I always wear shorts. It pisses off some of the right people.

WWIII Joe Biden, Husk-Puppet + America's Putin said...

The View- The tired formula that seems to work for the left-networks.
A pack of tired clichéd she-libs shouting down the token conservative.
Oh boy!

Trooper York said...

Well wearing pants can be a problem when you are reviewing photos of the Russian Navy.

Sydney said...

I do not miss the internet when I am away from it. I stopped watching television regularly in the late 1980's. Haven't missed it one bit.

Anonymous said...

I think I most definitley would have some symptoms of withdrawal from the internet, sadly. With a mobile device like an iPhone it's just too convenient.

Methadras said...

I watch a ton of tv. Well, let me rephrase that. I watch a ton of TV that my wife records on the DVR and plays back. My tv time has gone to hell and I have no way to reclaim it with all of the reality shows I must endure. Hey, at least I know what happened on the Bachelorette last night. Ask me.

Aridog said...

Icepick said...

If Honey Boo Boo is cancelled the terrorists have won?

Trooper York said...

If the cancel the show featuring toothless illiterate goobers than how will anyone know what it is like to live in Florida? Just sayn'...

Well if we walked away from the computer we would have to put on pants.

Icepick said...

You go commando on the intertubez? Not me. I always wear shorts. It pisses off some of the right people.

Who needs TV when you have this level of comedy. Or maybe it's just me...damn near fell off my chair laughing with that "what it's like to live in Florida" line.

I manage to go to rural Montan periodically where I have no television, just books and the Internet via WiFi Verizon Hot Spot....for my travel laptop. No, my cell phone is one of those Jurassic devices that just takes and makes phone calls.

virgil xenophon said...

"My cellphone is one of those Jurassic devices.."

You too, eh? :)

Icepick said...

Well wearing pants can be a problem when you are reviewing photos of the Russian Navy.

I do take the shorts off for special occasions such as you describe.

Icepick said...

Or maybe it's just me...damn near fell off my chair laughing with that "what it's like to live in Florida" line.

Ari, my problem with the line is that there are about 37 people from NYC down here for every person born in Florida. There are about 300 Haitians, Dominicans, Cubans, Puerto Ricans (NOT originally from NYC) and Mexicans for every person from Florida. Just heard a survey today that only about four or five thousand people left in the state actually speak English in their homes. I WISH the state was still full of goobers because then I could actually find someone that still spoke English when I left the house.

The three worst things that ever happened to Florida are air conditioning, Hitler and Bill Clinton, roughly in that order. If it weren't for that unholy trio, there'd be little of interest down here, which would be a vast improvement over all the New Yorkers who can't read a damned ballot and all the serial killers that come here from everywhere else, because FLA is Mecca to serial killers. Give Florida back to the goobers, the mosquitoes, the alligators and the orange groves!

/ nativist rant

virgil xenophon said...

Considering his rant, Icepick must be a big fan of carl "Sick Puppies" hiaasan, lol.

(PS: I'm currently into his latest read, "Bad Monkey"--another burst-the-stomach-surgery-stitches-from-laughing killer, lol)

Icepick said...

Considering his rant, Icepick must be a big fan of carl "Sick Puppies" hiaasan, lol.

I have trouble reading Hiaasen. What everyone else thinks is humor writing is nothing more than mere journalism. It's good, it's just depressing as Hell when you're living it.

Aridog said...

Icepick ... I have a dear friend who is a native born Floridian, and although a very good engineer, living near Jacksonville now, he agrees with you on this...

Give Florida back to the goobers, the mosquitoes, the alligators and the orange groves!

On point, I doubt the word "My-YAMmie is the native pronunciation.

XRay said...

I'm a Jacksonville native. It was a wonderful place to grow up, back then. I last visited in 79 or so... damn place had gone to hell. I gave up TV for the internet, other than being a passive observer while my wife watches. I did 4 days without internet on a recent cruise... no withdrawal symptoms, course I knew it was waiting for me, that probably helped. Good catch on the cig, the good old days.

Icepick said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Icepick said...

You think they mangle Miami badly, you should hear 'em say "FLAAAAAAAH-rid-uh".

ricpic said...

There was once the technology of story telling by a story teller. I know I'm stretching the term technology but in the sense that certain elders in every small grouping or tribe of humans had developed superior techniques for the telling of stories, in that sense story telling constituted a technology. And what was more magical and meaningful than the little band gathering around the elder, all of them around a fire, as the elder weaved their story? That, which was once both common and necessary is now a rarity. Robbed from us by the newer technologies that according to this post make us "human." Ha, sez I.

Unknown said...

You think they mangle Miami badly, you should hear 'em say "FLAAAAAAAH-rid-uh".

August 6, 2013 at 5:31 PM


I resemble that remark (Jersey girl, though I mostly grew up in New Orleans.) Hubs and I met in Jacksonville and he still ribs me about the pronounciation.

Still, I do love those Flaarida aaaranges.

Lydia said...

And what was more magical and meaningful than the little band gathering around the elder, all of them around a fire, as the elder weaved their story? That, which was once both common and necessary is now a rarity.

I took my six-year-old granddaughter to school a couple of months ago. We were early and the teacher wasn't there yet, but an older girl was reading to several of the children. They were all completely caught up in the reading. And they could have instead been playing games on the several computers around the room.

Anyway, just to say that I don't think all hope is lost.

deborah said...

That's a good point, ricpic, and I'd say story telling is a tool.

You misread my point though. My question was how far is too far before we lose something through having too much tech. Google Glass is only the beginning.

But man am I hooked on my GPS. I would hate being without it.

deborah said...

Lydia, I was thinking of reading aloud being the next step after story-telling. But I guess it would be dramatic plays, then reading aloud, then radio...

deborah said...

Agreed, Troop, The View is loathsome. As are Lifetime Movies.

virgil xenophon said...

@icepick

I have several fraternity brothers from Orlando (one had a beach-house at New Smyrna and we used to stage out of there for spring-break at Daytona Beach--'course New Smyrna is all beachfront hi-rise condos now and unrecognizable from that time, I've been told.) and the Tampa area (me, LSU, '66) To show you what a fossil I am the last time I was in Orlando was pre-Disney, when it (and its 26 lakes) really was "The City Beautiful." LOL Of course even then all the action was moving out to the Winter Park area, iirc.

Known Unknown said...

Slightly OT: Honor Blackman is killing zombies in the movie Cockneys vs. Zombies.

deborah said...

lol thanks for staying slightly on topic, EMD. Opens this Friday, wow. I thought you were going to link to a 60's grade B movie.

But wait, there’s more – including Honor Blackman, a.k.a. Pussy Galore, blasting zombies back to the Stone Age. In fact, it’s an unusually accomplished cast, including the late, great Richard Briers (recognizable from the Britcom The Good Life and Branagh’s Shakespearean films) with a machine gun strapped to his walker. Lovejoy’s Dudley Sutton also gets in on the act, but Alan Ford (a Guy Ritchie regular) really steals the biscuit as ornery old Ray “Don’t Call Me Grandpa” McGuire.

Thank you.

Anonymous said...

deborah: Good topic. I've been meaning to revisit McLuhan to see how well his work pans out in retrospect.

That we live in a global village is clear.

"The medium is the massage" -- I suppose, though I'm not sure what the consequences are if true.

The main effect of television, I'd say, has been to soak up huge amounts of discretionary time in passive viewing to the detriment of card and board games, story telling, amateur music, parties, hobbies, and reading, rather than some vague handwaving about hot vs. cool media.

The only sixties futurist that holds up IMO is Herman Kahn, who predicted a propserous technological future in which the real danger would be the war of what he called the New Class against the middle class. He described the New Class thus:

Think of a group of people who come from upper middle class backgrounds, from families who are largely education-oriented, so they see that the children go to the good schools and who, after they get out of the schools, earn their living by the use of academic skills, language skills, esthetic skills, analytical skills. They don't earn their living by being entrepreneurs, businessmen, engineers, laborers, clerical workers.

--Herman Kahn from talk given at Gov. Jerry Brown's office in 1976

Anonymous said...

At in the discussion following Kahn's talk, Brown said, with surprising cogency given his politics then and now:

It seems to me that the curve you're plotting shows that this country politically or technologically collapses in 10 or 15 years, and some other country takes over because they don't have the burden of this New Class that was produced by all this technological progress.

Thank you. And now back to your regularly scheduled massage, er, programming.

deborah said...

Great thoughts, creeley. Yeah, the cold and hot strikes me as hand-wavy.

Ha, I just went looking for an elusive McLuhan quote again, and met myself looking for the quote another time:

"I went looking for a McLuhan quote I like...something about the television screen being thin, yet infinite. The quotes I saw though were awfully bullshitty/dated sounding."

http://althouse.blogspot.com/2012/01/cathy-n-davidson-english-professor-at.html

Anonymous said...

deborah: Ah, well, apparently you were on to the good doctor early on.

I've got some McLuhan on my bookshelves but beyond a few catchprases and his literary magpie writing style, I don't remember any of it.

I do sorta miss the grand 20th century era of intellectual/guru/con-men like McLuhan, Norman Brown, Werner Erhard, Timothy Leary, Gurdjieff, R.D. Laing, G. Spencer Brown, John Lilly, Frank Lloyd Wright, Fritz Perls, Carlos Castaneda, Terence McKenna, J.D. Salinger, Rudolph Steiner, Wilhelm Reich, Alan Watts and no doubt others who have slipped my mind.

Not that these people were entirely fraudulent, but they acquired ridiculously inflated reputations for knowingness beyond ordinary folks.

We don't have many of the intellectual/guru/con-men breed roaming about these days. The one in the White House is but a shrunken descendant.

Anonymous said...

Here's an odd bit of McLuhan that was the introduction to "Subliminal Seduction" by Wilson Bryan Key, a colleague of McLuhan's at the University of Western Ontario. "Subliminal Seduction" was the watershed book that set off the big alarums about subliminal advertising in the seventies.

The power-starved person can easily see himself getting top coverage if he is involved in a sufficiently outrageous act of hijacking or mayhem. The older pattern of success story by achievement simply takes too long to be practical at electric speeds. Why not make the news instead of a life?

The close relation between sex and violence, between good news and bad news, helps to explain the compulsion of the admen to dunk all their products in sex by erogenizing every contour of every bottle or cigarette. Having reached this happy state where the good news is fairly popping, the admen say, as it were: "Better add a bit of the bad news now to take the hex off all that bonanza stuff." Let's remind them that LOVE, replayed in reverse, is EVOL--transposing into EVIL and VILE. LIVE spells backward into EVIL, while EROS reverses into SORE. And, we should never forget the SIN in SINCERE or the CON in CONFIDENCE.
Let's tighten up the slack sentimentality of this goo with something gutsy and grim.

As Zeus said to Narcissus:

"Watch yourself."

MARSHALL MCLUHAN


Love that last bit!

deborah said...

Hmmm...no such thing as bad press?